Monday, July 26, 2004

AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED

By William Fisher

Most of the world – and especially the Arab world – believes that Jews are Jews are Jews, that they are totally homogenous, and that all their views on all Israeli-related issues are the same. They all favor the policies of Ariel Sharon. They are all in favor of ‘the wall’. They all support the proposed Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. They all believe that settlements in the West Bank and Gaza are God-given rights. And they all charge that all Arabs want to drive Israel into the sea.

Neither in the US nor in Israel do the facts on the ground support these conclusions. In Israel, Left-leaning and Right-leaning political parties and media have been locked in fierce debate for many years. The same deeply felt differences are mirrored in the United States. What is true in the US is that dissenters from American ‘conventional wisdom’ on Israel do not get anything like the financial support, press coverage or attention from office-seeking politicians afforded to more powerful and well-connected groups such as the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC).

As Esther Kaplan wrote recently in her article ‘The Jewish Divide on Israel’ in the Nation magazine: “AIPAC and the Conference of Presidents (of Major Jewish Organizations), along with their powerful fellow travelers, Christian Zionists, have forged a bipartisan consensus in Washington that Middle East policy must privilege the ‘special relationship’ between the United States and Israel. In practice, this solid consensus means putting Israeli security before peace; supporting even such extreme Israeli measures as the separation wall and assassinations; and delegitimizing the Palestinian leadership.”

Yet there is much evidence that groups representing alternative views are growing in both numbers and in influence. For example, ever since the 1993 Oslo Accord proved that negotiations were possible, surveys have consistently found that 50 to 60 percent of American Jews favor ending the occupation and dismantling settlements in return for peace.
While there is little likelihood that this growth will be very visible in an election year – Israel is the ‘third rail’ of American politics – expect these voices to be get a lot more attention after November. 

Who are these groups and what are their views?

One of them is the Chicago-based Brit Tzedek v'Shalom, (the Jewish Alliance for Justice and Peace), co-founded in 2002 by Marcia Freedman, a former Knesset member. Brit Tzedek is a national grassroots membership organization representing 16,000 members with chapters in twenty-seven cities. It supports a negotiated settlement to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict based roughly on the 1967 borders, sharing Jerusalem, and evacuation of settlements. It asserts that security for Israel can only be achieved through the establishment of an economically and politically viable Palestinian state, an end to Israel's occupation of land acquired during the 1967 war, and to Palestinian terrorism.

Another group is the Berkeley-based Tikkun Community. It calls on the Palestinian people to acknowledge the right of Jews to maintain their own homeland in the pre-1967 borders of the state of Israel, with Jewish control over the Jewish section of Jerusalem and the Western Wall. It calls on the Palestinian people to stop acts of terror against Israel and opposes Israel’s violations of Palestinian human rights.

The Oakland-based Jewish Voice for Peace, was founded in 1996, when, “despite three years of participating in a ‘peace process’ under the Oslo accords, Palestinians and Israelis seemed increasingly unlikely to achieve the peace they claimed to seek.”  JVP members were especially concerned that the Israeli government was continuing to build settlements in the Occupied West Bank, Gaza Strip, and East Jerusalem. It organized more than 100 people to protest at the Israeli consulate in San Francisco, becoming one of the first US Jewish groups to criticize Israeli treatment of Palestinians.

Jews Against the Occupation, an organization in the New York City area, rejects the notion that it is "necessary" to subjugate Palestinians for the sake of keeping Jews safe; claims that that security can only come from mutual respect, and that the occupation of Palestine is only worsening the position of Jews in the Middle East and around the world; opposes the demolition of Palestinian houses and crops in the Occupied Territories; calls for an end to U.S. government aid to Israel; and opposes the Israeli Government’s “attack the Palestinian economy.”

Meretz USA, an affiliate of Israel's left-wing Meretz Party, calls itself  “a progressive Zionist organization that educates Americans about issues of civil rights and peace in Israel.” It sees “no alternative to renewing the search for peace between Israel and the Palestinian people, establishing and sustaining a cease-fire, and taking basic measures conducive to the renewal of meaningful negotiations leading to the creation of a sovereign, demilitarized Palestinian state.” The organization has consistently opposed building Jewish settlements in the occupied territories.

These are but a few of the so-called non-mainstream organizations. Some of the newer groups are cooperating with older outfits like Americans for Peace Now (APN), which pushes for active White House and State Department engagement in the peace process, especially Administration efforts to broker a new interim understanding between Israelis and Palestinians, facilitate final status arrangements that reconcile Israeli security with Palestinian statehood, and encourage negotiations between Israel, Syria, and Lebanon.

What are these groups doing to make their views heard?

There is a long menu of initiatives. For example, in March, one of the older peace groups, Rabbis for Human Rights of North America, sent an open letter to Sharon protesting Israel's house-demolition policy, which was signed by 400 rabbis, including leaders of some of the largest congregations in the country. In April, Brit Tzedek organized 10,000 US Jews to sign another open letter calling on Israel and the US to fund the relocation of Jewish settlers from the occupied territories to Israel.

Though these groups lack support from major Jewish donors or Jewish foundations, their numbers are growing. APN has some 25,000 supporters; Brit Tzedek, 17,000. There would seem to be substantial room for growth, approaching AIPAC’s 65,000 membership.
But there is diversity of opinion even among these groups. About the only thing they all agree on is Israel’s right to exist. On every other issue, as Esther Kaplan notes, “American Jews are as polarized on Israel as Americans as a whole are polarized about George W. Bush.” 

 

 

35 comments:

  1. So many blogs and only 10 numbers to rate them. I'll have to give you a 7 because you have good content but lack of quality posts.

    Free Access To More Information Aboutearly childhood education program

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice site i came here searching for teen make money online and was looking for other people who are interested in teen make money online
    You might be interested in teen make money online

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey i got here searching for affiliate program information
    Your sites not too bad!

    You got good rankings for them keywords affiliate program information

    Check out my site
    affiliate program information

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello,

    I LOVE you blog. I thought your visitor may also like to see this site on office uk virtual. It's a good resource so!

    Here's the site: office uk virtual Info Site

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi BILL, this is my last visit on the 'net for now - I'm tired. I found AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED by accident as I'm searching on usana network marketing but I got fed up with that and I've been roaming about just reading what takes my fancy. Good blog you have here, I enjoyed my visit. Have a great day and it's back to usana network marketing searches for me tomorrow.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Aloha BILL, I'm in Hawaiian mood as I'm listening to Ki ho'alu music (If you've not heared this type of guitar music then you are in for a treat!) so I'm not really concentrating very hard but I came across AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED looking up gen on usana network marketing. Anything to do with usana network marketing I always look at, though I do have a tendency to wander about in blogs just reading generally.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Government grant money and loans are available for business, personal use and much more, get government money. Start now and find grant money for business, education, housing and government finanial help now.

    ReplyDelete
  8. hey speaking of free things try blingo for free white pagesfree, its free to sign up and you can win free prizes! I just won a free movie ticket! Lets win together!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Handy Portrait Tips!

    Preparation for your Family Portrait.

    Always decide what type of sitting you'd like to have, your Purpose...

    Individual - Perfect for special occasions and presents for parents.

    Family - Capture the smiles and joy of the entire family!

    Group - Two or more people, catch those siblings interacting and playing!
    Group pictures are the perfect gifts for relatives!

    Combinations - capture the smiles of your children individually, as well as some
    poses together. Don't forget to include yourself in some of these portraits,
    an individual portrait taken with Mom or Dad let's them know how special they
    are! Select a time that works best with your family's schedule. Are your
    children typically more relaxed in the morning or afternoon? Generally...
    children photograph best when they are well rested and fed.

    Also what style would you like?

    Decide the type of "look" you want, e.g., classical, casual, contemporary, candid etc.


    Children's Portraits...

    Let their personalities shine through! personalise your portraits by bringing a special
    book, project or favorite toy.

    Young toddlers are sometimes the trickiest to prepare. They quickly pick up on stress
    and may become nervous, so always keep it fun and don't rehearse the sitting. Arrive
    early and let the photographer get to know your child. When selecting clothing, keep
    in mind what everybody is wearing to keep harmony with the overall look.

    Family Portraits...
    Keep it fun fun fun! Remember, children will quickly pick up on stress!
    Avoid the last minute rush by preparing your clothing early.
    While family portraits are very special, don't forget to take this opportunity to have
    a portrait taken of you and your partner together. Have the photographer take individual
    shots of each of the children, as well as all of the siblings together. Have a special
    portrait taken with Mom and the children for Dad's desk at work, and vice-versa.
    When selecting clothing, keep in mind what everybody is wearing to keep harmony with
    the overall look. If in doubt always bring a backup in the car handy.


    Lights! Camera! Action!

    Bring a brush and wipes to tame fly-away strands of hair, dribbles etc...
    For toddlers, bring a dry snack and drink, something that will not soil their clothes.
    Arrive a few minutes early. Don't let last minute traffic and delays create stress for
    this important event! Let the photographer interact with your child to make him/her more
    comfortable. If your child cries, don't worry our photographers can usually stop the tears
    within moments! Most importantly, have fun! A professional portrait is meant to capture
    the moment, and not force it!
    For many more ideas and tips about professional photographer sydney
    can be found professional photographer sydney

    ReplyDelete
  10. Greetings BILL, I'm looking for information and chat about lead marketing mlm network prospect sale and came across your site. There are some views in AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED that I can take on board. I used lead marketing mlm network prospect sale as one of my search terms which is how I came to visit your site. Enjoyed the read, I'll make note to come back again.

    ReplyDelete
  11. So you need a payday loan uk

    Get a payday loan uk at Easy Loans UK

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hi BILL, oh dear, I'm getting square eyed here - must have been spending too much time reading blogs and downline mlm network marketing information. I'm supposed to be looking for downline mlm network marketing items but I find it all too easy just to click 'Next' and just see anything which is how I came to AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED. Some blogs I just skip through but I spent a while here. Ciao.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Greetings BILL, I'm looking for information and chat about acn network marketing and came across your site. There are some views in AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED that I can take on board. I used acn network marketing as one of my search terms which is how I came to visit your site. Enjoyed the read, I'll make note to come back again.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Greetings BILL, I'm looking for information and chat about lead marketing mlm network prospect sale and came across your site. There are some views in AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED that I can take on board. I used lead marketing mlm network prospect sale as one of my search terms which is how I came to visit your site. Enjoyed the read, I'll make note to come back again.

    ReplyDelete
  15. where i get more info?

    ReplyDelete
  16. Aloha BILL, I'm in Hawaiian mood as I'm listening to Ki ho'alu music (If you've not heard this type of guitar music then you are in for a treat!) so I'm not really concentrating very hard but I came across AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED looking up gen on downline mlm network marketing. Anything to do with downline mlm network marketing I always look at, though I do have a tendency to wander about in blogs just reading generally.

    ReplyDelete
  17. G'day BILL, what a great blog you have here, been entertained by the read. Just noticed that my brief time visiting blogs looking for lead marketing mlm network prospect sale items has run into a couple of hours. Easily done when you get engrossed in what people write about. I should really use lead marketing mlm network prospect sale as a search term but then I might miss places such as AMERICAN JEWS DIVIDED. Besides which working all the time is boring.

    ReplyDelete
  18. nice information

    ReplyDelete
  19. good information

    ReplyDelete
  20. Dieses ist ein guter schauender Aufstellungsort!Byebye, Yuette debt consolidation mortgage california

    ReplyDelete
  21. What is the impact going to be in the end?Chiao, Jorge absolutely no fax payday loan

    ReplyDelete
  22. Ringraziamenti per avere un blog che include questo.Candidly, Donella debt consolidation mortgage california

    ReplyDelete
  23. Ich sch�tze die Gelegenheit, einen faxless cash advance Pfosten zu lassen.With Respect, Stephine faxless cash advance

    ReplyDelete
  24. Quelle est la meilleure mani�re d'aller avec ceci ?So long, Kenyatta 2500 fax loan no payday

    ReplyDelete
  25. I end up going with what feels best.Compliments, Guadalupe cash advance st louis

    ReplyDelete
  26. It's nice to have another source of personal loans for college students information.Respectfully, Lynn personal loans for college students

    ReplyDelete
  27. Was ist die beste Weise, mit diesem zu gehen?Best Wishes, Alejandra mortgage loan officer college certificate

    ReplyDelete
  28. Are you ilooking for ge wellness plan information? I have been searching for ge wellness plan information and came across your blog. Some good post you have. Hope my search for ge wellness plan is useful to you.

    ReplyDelete
  29. If you struggle with bad credit, credit card debt, or are facing bankruptcy, our bankruptcy/dect counselling resources can help you understand your finances better and help you improve your financial standing. If your site is of simmilar interest contact me and link sites.
    Debt Resources Services.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Debt elimination services can help consumers who have more debt than they can manage look into options of reducing or negating that debt. When searching for debt elimination, consumers should seek an agency that offers debt counselling and guidance based on an individual's unique circumstance.
    If your site is of similar interest contact me and link sites.
    Debt Resources Services.

    ReplyDelete
  31. This is a excellent blog. Keep it going. If you have a mortgage issue, I'm sure you'd be interested in http://thehomemortgageguide.com Need Information on purchasing a home? best refinance mortgage rate

    ReplyDelete
  32. �Usted ha o�do buenas noticias sobre best ionic air purifiers �ltimamente?Chiao, Ollie best ionic air purifiers

    ReplyDelete
  33. Christmas is just around the corner. No time to go to the mall...then do your shopping online. We sell everything that the mall sells. Shop today!

    ReplyDelete
  34. Christmas is just around the corner. No time to go to the mall...then do your shopping online. We sell everything that the mall sells. Shop today!

    ReplyDelete